Luck or Harbaugh-Your Thoughts

My question of the Day on Twitter was; If your team stinks and you need both a QB and a coach, and could only have one of them, would you want Andrew Luck or Jim Harbaugh.

Here are some of your responses:

Broncfan07 Tom Cammalleri 

@ 

@GusRamsey Rather have Luck. (and are they ever gonna need it...)

11 minutes ago 

»

GTGreenhorn Christopher Reilly 

@ 

@GusRamsey Andrew Luck coaches come and go but if you get a franchise QB, you're for 10 years

40 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply

janjan Jan 

@ 

@GusRamsey college coaches and their track record compared to "the greatest qb talent since elway" + longevity: coach maybe 3 yrs - qb 10

2 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply

zucknasty Matt Zucker 

@ 

@GusRamsey all starts with the coach, no player is a sure thing

2 hours ago 

memphiscds chad smithers 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck. Look at Peyton, he has made Dungy + Caldwell look smart. M Ryan and Freeman done same for Smith and Morris

2 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply

RajivVarma Rajiv Varma 

@ 

@GusRamsey Harbaugh. Coaches harder to find than quality quarterbacks.

2 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply

YoungMasterSon Daniel Stave 

@gusRamsey luck. Harbaugh is good coach prospect. Luck is said to be great Qb prospect

2 hours ago 

chidavidi David Broner 

@ 

@GusRamsey luck. You can get a coach next year. Probably can't get qb nearly as good next year.

2 hours ago 

SirJohnCard Chris J. 

@ 

@GusRamsey Take the QB. Montana, Elway, Marino, Favre, Manning all had more than one head coach.

2 hours ago 

ESPNClem Clem 

@ 

@GusRamsey I'll take the QB. Luck

2 hours ago 

TomMcGovern Thomas McGovern 

@ 

@GusRamsey A Good QB makes a bad Coach look good...and Bad QB makes a good coach look bad. Take the QB Andrew Luck.

2 hours ago 

ccarrigan1116 Connor Carrigan 

@ 

@GusRamsey harbough. Seems like Stanford draws personality, chippiness from him, not Luck. Bad teams need new mentalities.

2 hours ago 

joshwrono Josh W 

@ 

@GusRamsey college team= Harbaugh, pro team= Luck

2 hours ago 

loakman loakman 

@ 

@GusRamsey Harbaugh. He can coach up the QB

2 hours ago 

houndonmydoor Steven Rosales 

@ 

@GusRamsey I'd take Luck.. because a true franchise qb changes team for decade

2 hours ago 

georgeyboy36 George Duryea 

@ 

@GusRamsey harbaugh for my 49ers.

2 hours ago 

BetBigDC Shae Cronin 

@ 

@GusRamsey Andrew Luck, without question or hesitation.

2 hours ago 

ljmohler Lincoln Mohler 

@ 

@GusRamsey Gotta go with QB. It is much easier to replace a coach, then a franchise QB. A franchise QB will make any coach look competant.

2 hours ago 

gabeibrahim Gabe Ibrahim 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck. A team can win w/o a coach(09 Vikings) or a average one(10 chiefs). But no team can win w/o QB who isn't good/great

2 hours ago 

broncos2121 kevin grant 

@ 

@GusRamsey my team does stink and I would rather have Luck

2 hours ago 

connorhuchton Connor Huchton 

@ 

@GusRamsey In the NFL, Andrew Luck. In college, Harbaugh. One of Harbaugh's greatest strengths (if not greatest) is recruiting.

2 hours ago 

rocrusso Rocco Russo 

@ 

@GusRamsey HC... a great QB can sometimes over come a bad QB but its rare and hard to sustain.. see Vikings for example A

2 hours ago 

kalten19 Kevin Alten 

@ 

@GusRamsey a GREAT QB can mask ALOT of coaching deficencies

2 hours ago 

JHeb1973 Joel Hebensperger 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck w/o a second of thought...

2 hours ago 

dingerc Kevin Bell 

@ 

@GusRamsey Harbaugh. Good coach, trust the lineage (John H.), and DEN has at least the semblance of a passing game (orton or Tebow).

2 hours ago 

Loosemonkeys Graham Burns 

@ 

@GusRamsey Harbaugh, if team stinks need to change culture and bring in more talent than just QB.

2 hours ago 

BerserkHippo Berserk Hippo 

@ 

@GusRamsey Great coach can make a great QB more than a great QB can make a great coach.

2 hours ago 

codyegetz Cody Getz 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck, a promising young quarterback will draw coaching talent.

2 hours ago 

JKells1 John Keller 

@ 

@GusRamsey Look at last year's Cards vs. this year's team. It's a QB league, first and foremost. Coaches are overrated.

2 hours ago 

stevedavis17111 Steven Davis 

@GusRamsey like Sparky Anderson once said, u know what makes a good coach? Good players.

2 hours ago 

nbfunt nbfunt 

@ 

@GusRamsey Peyton or Dungy? Peyton. Elway or Shanny? Elway. Favre or Holmgren? Favre.QB's always win w/o coaches, coaches always need qb.

2 hours ago 

AMirch729 Adam M. Mirchin 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck. Not even close to close. You can always buy a good coach. Franchise QB's come around twice a decade.

2 hours ago 

anmarkevich Andrei Markevich 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck. I don't trust college coaches coming to the NFL. And I'm a 49ers fan. We need a QB who is even halfway competent.

2 hours ago 

rianp rianp 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck. We've had three coaches, but only one Manning since 98, seems to be a no brainer in this league.

2 hours ago 

manymuchmoosen Jody Canaday 

@ 

@GusRamsey Supply and demand dictates you take Luck. QB has biggest impact on your team AND make coach look like a genius (Shanahan nodding)

2 hours ago 

oompaz Nick Roberts 

@ 

@GusRamsey I'd rather have Luck no doubt.. If he's the next Elway that would outweight Harbaugh being the next Harbaugh.

2 hours ago 

JohnJMcG John McGuinness 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck easily. Record of college coaches in NFL is not good. Can always go get a coach.

2 hours ago 

21millst Men of Mill 

@ 

@GusRamsey As a 49ers I would take Harbaugh... I think there needs to be a culture change and we've seen top 10 qbs not pan out.

2 hours ago 

SchroederJon jon schroeder 

@ 

@GusRamsey As a Niners fan I'll take the coach.

2 hours ago 

dlen_wcu Daniel Leonard 

@ 

@GusRamsey my team, buffalo does stink. badly. but i really think fitz is capable. not too sure about gailey. so i'd have to take the coach

2 hours ago 

AdamLiebman Adam Liebman 

@ 

@GusRamsey good coach can help bad qb get better, good qb can't do anything if coach not good enough to run team well.

2 hours ago 

Spkonitwithtre tre mosley 

@ 

@GusRamsey sounds like the #jacksonvillejaguars

2 hours ago 

Brenden_Welsh Brenden Welsh 

@ 

@GusRamsey Luck, top QB prospect, many college coaches fail in the NFL.

2 hours ago